RSS Nationalism vs. Constitutional Nationalism: Comparison

 Comparison: RSS Nationalism vs. Constitutional Nationalism

 


RSS Nationalism (Hindutva Ideology)

The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), founded in 1925 by Keshav Baliram Hedgewar, is a Hindu nationalist organization that promotes Hindutva—a concept coined by V.D. Savarkar in 1923, defining Indian identity through ethnic, cultural, and civilizational ties to Hinduism. RSS nationalism envisions India as a "Hindu Rashtra" (Hindu nation), emphasizing Hindu unity, discipline, and cultural revival through daily "shakhas" (branches) involving physical training, ideological education, and community service. It operates as a volunteer paramilitary-style group with affiliates in education, labor, politics (e.g., the Bharatiya Janata Party or BJP), and religion under the Sangh Parivar umbrella.

Historically, the RSS was banned three times in India (1948 after Gandhi's assassination, 1975 during the Emergency, and 1992 after the Babri Masjid demolition) for promoting communalism and violence. It initially rejected key republican symbols: refusing to hoist the Tricolor flag until 2002, boycotting the national anthem, and criticizing the Constitution as a "Western patchwork" lacking references to ancient Hindu texts like the Manusmriti. In 1949, to lift the ban, RSS chief M.S. Golwalkar pledged loyalty to the Constitution and flag, leading to a formal RSS constitution. However, critics argue its core ideology remains at odds with secularism, viewing non-Hindus (e.g., Muslims, Christians) as potential "internal
threats" unless assimilated into Hindu culture.

Today, under Sarsanghchalak Mohan Bhagwat, the RSS influences policy via the BJP (e.g., Prime Minister Narendra Modi's RSS background), advocating "cultural nationalism" over explicit "nationalism" to distance from associations with Nazism or fascism. Recent events, like Karnataka Minister Priyank Kharge's 2025 call for banning RSS activities in public spaces, highlight ongoing tensions, with detractors labeling it "anti-national" for fostering division.

Constitutional Nationalism



Constitutional nationalism in India refers to patriotism rooted in the Indian Constitution (adopted 1950), which establishes India as a sovereign, secular, socialist, democratic republic. It prioritizes unity in diversity, equality, federalism, and fundamental rights for all citizens regardless of religion, caste, or ethnicity. This form of nationalism emerged from the freedom struggle led by the Indian National Congress (INC), emphasizing non-violence, inclusivity, and constitutional methods over ethnic or religious exclusivity. Icons like Jawaharlal Nehru and B.R. Ambedkar championed it, rejecting majoritarianism in favor of pluralism—India's 80% Hindu majority coexists with Muslims,
Christians, Sikhs, and others under equal protection.

It manifests in honoring national symbols (flag, anthem), upholding secular laws (e.g., no state religion), and democratic institutions. Policies like affirmative action for marginalized groups and opposition to communal violence exemplify this. Critics of alternatives like RSS ideology see constitutional nationalism as the antidote to divisiveness, aligning with global norms of civic patriotism.

Comparison: RSS Nationalism vs. Constitutional Nationalism

Aspect

RSS Nationalism (Hindutva)

Constitutional Nationalism
Core Ideology

Cultural/ethnic Hindu identity; India as Hindu Rashtra.

Civic/secular; unity via Constitution, equality for all.

View of Nation

Defined by Hindu ancestry, heritage, and assimilation of minorities.

Inclusive republic; diversity as strength, no dominant religion.

Historical Stance on Constitution

Initially rejected (1940s-50s) as "un-Indian"; pledged loyalty in 1949 under pressure.

Framed and defended by framers like Ambedkar; basis of post-1947 nation-building.

Approach to Minorities

Often views them as threats unless "Hinduized"; linked to communal tensions.

Protects via secularism; promotes interfaith harmony and rights.

Symbols & Practices

Delayed adoption of flag/anthem; paramilitary shakhas for Hindu discipline.

Full embrace of Tricolor, anthem; democratic elections and pluralism.

Influence Today

Shapes BJP policies (e.g., CAA/NRC debates); accused of majoritarianism.

Upheld by opposition (e.g., INC); basis for judicial interventions against hate.

Criticisms

Seen as fascist-like, divisive; bans tied to violence (e.g., 1992).

Accused by RSS of being "pseudo-secular" or weak on national security.

In essence, RSS nationalism seeks to redefine India through Hindu primacy, often clashing with constitutional nationalism's emphasis on secular equity. While the RSS claims alignment today, historical and ongoing debates (e.g., 2020 Bhagwat's rephrasing of "nationalism") underscore deep ideological rifts. For deeper reading, sources like Wikipedia's RSS entry or The Hindu's analyses provide balanced perspectives.
Source: Grok

Comments

Post a Comment

Golwalkar Mission of Hindu Rashtra

  FIR against the people who made bad remark on CJI Gavai of Supreme court   The controversy stems from remarks made by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Bhushan Ramkrishna (B.R.) Gavai on September 16, 2025, during a Supreme Court hearing on a petition seeking the reconstruction and reinstallation of a 7-foot idol of Lord Vishnu at the Javari Temple in Madhya Pradesh's Khajuraho (a UNESCO World Heritage site). CJI Gavai, heading the bench, dismissed the plea as a "publicity interest litigation" and remarked, "Go and ask the deity himself to do something. If you are saying that you are a strong devotee of Lord Vishnu, then you pray and do some meditation." These comments were perceived by some as mocking Hindu beliefs, sparking widespread outrage on social media and leading to casteist and derogatory posts targeting CJI Gavai, who is from the Scheduled Caste (SC) community and the third Dalit CJI in India's history. The situation escalated on October 6, 202...
Read more

The Sanatan Dharma in Crisis in Indian Politics

Image
 T he Sanatan Dharma in Crisis in Indian Politics The term "Sanatan Crisis" (often spelled "Sanatana Crisis") has emerged in Indian political discourse to describe a series of escalating controversies, rhetorical battles, and social tensions surrounding Sanatana Dharma —the "eternal order" or traditional framework of Hinduism. It encapsulates debates over the role of Hindu identity in national politics, accusations of majoritarianism, and perceived existential threats to Hindu traditions from conversions, opposition rhetoric, and minority appeasement. While rooted in the 2023 remarks by Tamil Nadu minister Udhayanidhi Stalin (who likened Sanatana Dharma to diseases like dengue and malaria, sparking nationwide outrage and Supreme Court petitions), the crisis has intensified in 2025 amid election cycles, communal polarization, and high-profile incidents. This has pitted the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and its ideological parent, the Rashtriya Swayam...
Read more

Atrocities against Dalits in BJP-Ruled States

Image
  Atrocities against Dalits in BJP-Ruled States Atrocities against Dalits (members of Scheduled Castes) remain a persistent issue in India, with official data from the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) showing a troubling rise in reported cases. Under the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) governments at the center and in several states, critics, including opposition leaders and human rights organizations, have highlighted a pattern of increased violence, often linked to caste discrimination. BJP-ruled states like Uttar Pradesh (UP), Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh (MP), and Odisha consistently top the charts for such crimes. While the government attributes higher reporting to greater awareness and better enforcement of laws like the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (PoA Act), activists argue that the surge reflects systemic failures and a permissive environment for caste-based violence. Key trends: National Increase : Crimes against Schedul...
Read more